The trailer that we saw for Avatar on the big screen looked very CGI to me. I actually thought it must be a movie of a video game at first, it has that low-res look. I’m prepared to go and see it with an open mind, but it annoys me how visible the computer generated special effects are in those kinds of movies. I mean, yes, I know they didn’t really find 9-foot-tall purple actors for the role, but the shadows and textures are never right. The shorts for Avatar had a kind of mistiness about the whole scene, like they’d blurred down the real stuff to match the resolution of the CG bits.
I find it deeply ironic that the special effects in the original 1970s Star Wars look more solid and real than modern stuff. Lord of The Rings being a notable exception. I guess James Cameron knows his stuff, so we’ll have to wait and see.
…
That Culture movie is an interesting thing. The short story is very very short. But you can’t really read it without knowing about the Culture, so they’ll need to pack a lot of exposition into the film. I think people suggesting making a full-length Culture novel into a movie don’t appreciate how many more words a novel has than a film, and how much explaining the Culture needs. I re-read Matter last week, and it struck me how much Banks’ novels are driven by dialogue and character. Plus screeds of exposition that are often mostly about character (albeit the character of a species or ship). That technique could actually work quite well in a movie, provided it gets a sympathetic treatment. And as long as they keep the humour. Maybe they could get Banks to narrate


